September 11, 2013I'm not sure the situation is as straightforward as it appears. The idea that they were planning to destroy us came from Janek, but Lindelof (the writer) hinted in [url=http://www.slashgear.com/ridley-scott-talks-prometheus-with-slashgear-candid-uncut-02231334/]an interview[/url] that Janek might be mistaken about that:
[quote][i]The movie demonstrates what [the black goo] does in certain circumstances. So, here’s what it does if it gets on worms; here’s what it does if it gets on your face; here’s what it does if someone just puts a little bit of it in your drink. So, now we see that that lots of this is headed to Earth. Now, you used the word “weapon”, you’re extrapolating that based on the theory [Prometheus captain] Janek has, because it looks like a payload to him: all these ships are loaded with this stuff, and they’re headed for Earth. The intent has to be to wipe us out, or is it to evolve us, or is it for something else?[/i][/quote]
In the scene where Charlie starts to get really sick, and they're racing back to the ship, you can see the skin on his face bubbling, and it looks a lot like the skin on the Engineer's head from the operation scene. Ford & Shaw said that the cells of the Engineer's head were undergoing some kind of change/mutation. They show Charlie's face again, right before he gets torched, and he is all pale and dark-eyed - as if he was mutating into an Engineer.
Take that, plus the 2000 yr old dead bodies (Jesus), plus the cup of alcohol that David put the drop of goo into (wine representing his blood), and I think there's a reasonable case to be made that they were coming to earth to "convert" us.
There's also the hologram that shows the Engie's preparing to leave for earth, and none of them look like theyr'e on a war mission. They're speaking very calmly to each other, and it looks like just a routine mission for them.
It might be that they kept humans like a stock of cattle or something, and if their numbers were low for whatever reason, they would come and morph some of us into them, so they could continue.
However, that doesn't explain their worship of the deacon, who is clearly a product of the black goo + human male + mating w/female + squid baby infecting an engineer.
I think we only got the tip of the iceberg with Prometheus, and although we can draw some conclusions from the information given, it's just not enough to suss out the whole story.